Site Meter Environmental Talk » Blog Archive » Psychologist Blinded By Science

Psychologist Blinded By Science

by

dolby1.jpg
Science!

USA Today had an interesting article suggesting that much of the “resistance to science” in the United States is due to psychology developed during childhood.

Among the more absurd claims made in the article is the assertion by Yale psychologist Paul Bloom that “to be scientifically educated means you have to pick up a lot of counter-intuitive beliefs.”

Explanations such as this certainly don’t help science’s case. The whole point of science is not “belief” but rather proof. The concept of picking up “counter-intuitive beliefs” further adds to the fun-house mirror effect. Not only are you supposed to “believe” something, but what you believe should be the opposite of what you thought you were going to believe before you picked up what you were believing. Or something like that.

The author of the article doesn’t understand the importance of scientific method and how it relates to certainty of knowledge, but one of the commenters does. Commenter cr pretty much nails it when he states:

“The difference between a scientific belief system and a theological belief system is pretty simple … If the DATA contradicts your theory, then a scientist challenges the theory, but a theologian will challenge the data.”

Game, set, match … to science.

, , , , , , ,


Leave a Reply


About Environmental Talk

Environmental Talk is a blog that attempts to do the impossible . . . which is to have a reasoned and nuanced approach to the science and issues surrounding global warming. At the same time, we are not above taking the occasional potshot at the extremists and posers on both sides of the topic.

As a global warming agnostic, blogger/moderator Mark Jabo attempts to come down squarely on the side of finding humor in what is, too often, a needlessly contentious topic.

Environmental Talk Author(s)

Blogging Flair






beTurtle seal of approval

Environment Channel Posts

  • Eco-ways put to good Use
    Several times here on Natural and Sustainable I talk about how important it is to use earth-friendly and eco building materials when you go to remodel or even change a room around in your home or [...]
  • Save even more at the Pump with these Cars
    It seemed there for awhile that the gas prices would never come down and more and more people were depending on public transportation and car pooling to get to where they were headed. Even with the [...]
  • Top 10 plants for better air quality in your home
    So I knew that having a plant in your house is a good idea.. but I didn't realize it was a GREAT idea.. An article by Nicholas Harter entitled Use Plants to Improve Your Indoor Air Quality [...]
  • Natural Vs. Organic, which is best?
    When it comes to earth-friendly options there are a lot out there to choose from. Names like pesticide-free, cage-free, natural, organic, earth-friendly, eco-friendly, etc. But when it comes to [...]
  • Stay on the Eco-Path with these Tips
    It may seem like an endless path to keep on when trying to choose the right products to keep on the eco-path. But, with a bit of knowledge about the best products that offer eco-good ways of [...]
  • Frozen Versus Canned: How to Eat Your Veggies in the Winter
    Americans don't seem all that keen on their fruits and veggies, or at least not as keen as they should be, unless we are talking potatoes. And especially when they eat out, Americans are more [...]
  • Need a Natural Cure? Get it with Honey
    Honey is one of naturals great natural remedies. It can help you get a boost of energy; make your cough subside as just give you that special sugary treat when you need it. But, did you know that [...]
  • How Green are Dishwashers Really?
    The best way to clean a sink of dishes is the ole' standby of a two bucket system. Fill up a bucket on one side of the sink with warm water and fill a bucket up on the other side of the sink with [...]
  • Natural and Sustainable Eco-Cleaning Tips
    We have all been there, running around the house to quickly clean our house on the weekend or on the weekday or even when someone is coming over. I have always said it seems no one ever comes to [...]
  • Practice Better Building Habits
    When it comes to building just about anything from a house to a small pump house, building practices are only good when they don't hurt the surrounding area or the earth as well. Here are a few [...]

Hot Off The Press